| 1974 | 1984 | 1998 | 2014 |
| T. Carlton Lewellyn | Conley H. Dishon | Ronnie Blaylock | Billy Bowman |
| Donald A. Hess | Edward Carney | Kay Martin | |
| 1975 | Douglas W. Kidd | Clifton Lockridge | Troy Stevenson |
| Otto B. Mangrum | Homer B. Spears | Anthony Panella | Tracy Waddell |
| Dennis K. Wickline | Jack H. Yates | Ruby Ann Foster Sebrell | Rachel Bavister |
| Schede Wynn | Ross Shoop | Race Drake | |
| 1976 | Virgil E. Hankins | Coach Al Deuel | |
| Jerold M. Grizzle | 2000 | ||
| 1985 | Bryan McGee | 2018 | |
| 1977 | James Dilettoso | Carol Harper | Donnie Dove, Jr. |
| Frank Mutter | Preston T. Newton | Charles Keen | Steve Daniels |
| Nat Waldron | Rodney E. Quillen | Gina Tester | Robert Arnold Augusta |
| Roy Farmer | William Ramos | Jimmy Dickens | Jim Fogelsong |
| Stephen C. Jones | Jimmy Kiser | Wayne Frick | |
| William Brizendine | 1986 | Kim Tyree | Sallie Mae Pauley |
| Arthur G. Allen | Mary Ann Lawson | Leonard Earl Wright | |
| 1978 | Chester W. Moyers, Jr. | Patti Ferebee | |
| Elmer Ralph Kiser | Edmond T. Abbott | Randy Wheeler | 2020 |
| Flae Calvin Shook | Fred P. Yates, Jr. | Richard Koch | Postponed |
| Granville Currier | Stanley Byers | ||
| 1987 | 2022 | ||
| 1979 | Durston M. Winesburg | 2003 | Postponed |
| Oliver W. McInturff | Johnny L. Olinger | John Walter Michaels | |
| Richard Barley | W. Leroy Christian | Senator Curry Carter | 2024 |
| Rocco J. DeVito | Rueben Swipe Weaver | Scott Bush (A) | |
| 1980 | Betty Roop Young | Samuel Edwards (A) | |
| Bernard W. Moore | 1988 | Glenn Patterson | Wesley Arey (C) |
| James B. Walton | George Wayne Heppert | Edwin Martin | Belinda McCleese (C) |
| Lewis J. Roop | James E. Burnette | Phillip Bottoms | Roberta Dietz (E) |
| Obie A. Nunn | John Abner Caudle, Jr. | Tonia Saunders | Frances Marzolf (E) |
| Billy Elliott | Wesley Arey (S) | ||
| 1981 | 1989 | Keith Minnis | Henry Balthazar (S) |
| Albert L. Fletcher | Allie W. Powell, Jr. | Mark Stevens (S) | |
| Charles K. Lockridge | Gordon Mack Harris | 2006 | |
| Clyde L. Cook | Ronnie D. Kiser | Janice Ellen Couch | |
| Glenn O. Coffey | Thomas Lee Rea | Mazie Helen Crews | |
| R. Morris Layton | Freda Christine Norman | ||
| 1990 | Jane Norman | ||
| 1982 | Jeffrey K. Spielberger | Shirley Ann Zimmerman | |
| Cecil R. Prillman | Ollie M. McCray | Linwood Canada | |
| Charles H. Dawson | Ronald L. Fadoul | Jeff Foster Jefferson | |
| J. Edward Howell | Ervin Calvin Neighbors | ||
| Frank T. Anderson, Jr. | 1994 | Dave Norman Tester | |
| Harold V. Taylor | Bennie Lacks | Andrew King | |
| Marshall J. Garrett | Harold Forestal | ||
| Otis B. Snead, Jr. | Harvey N. Cunningham | 2010 | |
| Paul V. Powers | James M. Searls | Donald Blankenship | |
| Warren C. Blackwell | Lewis S. Harper | Bill Webb | |
| William Brightwell | Robert A. Mawyer, Jr. | Victor Haynes | |
| Wyatt W. Martin | Ronald D. Noel | Kenneth Potter | |
| T. Vernon Cherry, Jr. | Steve O. Shrum | Findlay Loving | |
| Terry W. Crisman | James Dunkley | ||
| 1983 | Winfrey E. Arnold | Daphne Cox | |
| Bernie Wilson | Mel Carter | ||
| Dock F. Yates | 1996 | Bob Daniels | |
| Ernest R. Prillman | David Inabinett | ||
| George M. Spady | Grady Spence | 2013 | |
| Gordon W. Landes | Job Turner | Mike Albis | |
| Jesse L. Smith | Merritt Belew | Tommy Cook | |
| Leo A. Yates | Montana Houchins | Tracy Parham | |
| Olin L. Creasy | Dawayne Werner | ||
| Ray S. Parks, Jr. | 1997 | Bill Sager | |
| Richard K. Hammock | Elizabeth Harper | ||
| Ryland R. Thomas | Joe Shinpaugh, Jr. | ||
| Thomas R. Harmon | Leora Ottaway Hinnant | ||
| Thomas W. Sullivan | Mary Scott Bass | ||
| Robert Aumon Bass |
Key (): A – Arts; C – Community Service; E – Education; S- Sports
|
The players listed below were selected for the Hall of Fame during the special Football Reunion held at the Virginia School for the Deaf and the Blind September 25, 2004 for their outstanding performance during the 1939, 1954 and 1969 seasons during which the teams were undefeated. |
| 1939 | 1954 | Melvin Ebron | Neal Clapp |
| Harry Moore | Randolph Wilson | Charles Alexander | Bennie Lacks |
| John Atwood | John Rusnak | Carl Sargent | Steve Burton |
| Harry Knicely | Edward McGann | Edward Holcomb | Kenneth Potter |
| William Brizendine | Homer Spears | Richard Fogle | Terry Crisman |
| Marshall Garrette | Ryland Thomas | T. C. Lewellyn | Mike Albis |
| Junior Cherry | Donald Hess | Jim Dilettoso | Charles Harris |
| Harold Taylor | Gordon Landes | Billy Elliott | |
| Melvin Crews | Virgil Hankins | 1969 | Kelly Short |
| Charles Dawson | Ray Parks | Edward Arnold | Findlay Loving |
| Leonard Conley | Billy Ramos | Jimmy Dickens | Paul Shifflett |
| Warren Blackwell | Jesse Smith | Johnny Olinger | Mike Yance |
| Paul Powers | Wade Webb | Steve Shrum | William Whiteside |
| Frank Anderson | Conley Dishon | Durston Winesburg | Steve Deavers |
| Edward Howell | Allen Williams | Sherman Harper | David Inabinett |
| Billy Brightwell | Billy Taylor | Ronald Noel | Jimmy Dunkley |
| Morris Layton | Wesley Kidd | Jack Cornette | Ken Crockett |
| Otis Snead | Ray Humphrey | Benny Warden | Rusty Craft |
| Schede Wynn | Charles Hall | Bobby Mawyer | Rocco DeVito |
| Ralph Kiser | Jack Yates | Matthew Searls | Glenn Patterson |
| T. C. Lewellyn | Charles Gill | Charles Keen | |
| LeRoy Ridings | Garland Robinson | Roger Petty |
|
The players listed below were selected for the Hall of Fame during the special Basketball Reunion held at the Virginia School for the Deaf and the Blind October 13, 2006 for their outstanding performance during the 1959, 1964 and 1970 seasons during which the teams were Mason-Dixon Basketball Tournament Champions. |
| 1959 | 1964 | 1970 |
| Charles Tolley | Chester Myers | Johnny Olinger |
| Harry Taylor | Wayne Heppert | Durston Winesburg |
| Tom Sullivan | Richard Dooley | Ronald Noel |
| Chester Moyers | Howard Reid | Bobby Mawyer |
| Wallace Currier | Ronnie Kiser | Steve Shrum |
| Phillip Shortt | Donald Drinkard | Steve Burton |
| Carroll Thomas | John Caudle | David Inabinett |
| Marvin Payne | Mack Harris | Jack Cornette |
| Ollie McCray | Calvin Glass | Roger Petty |
| Billy Bowman | Chick Crawford | Edward Arnold |
| Charles Alexander | Jim Pedersen | Rocco DeVito |
| Jim Dilettoso |
|
The cheerleaders listed below were selected for the Hall of Fame during the Alumni Reunion held at the Virginia School for the Deaf and the Blind October 9, 2010 for their outstanding performance during the 1969-1970 season. |
|
1969-1970 Cheerleaders |
||
| Diane Haynes | Vicki (Hall) Milford | Penny Cecil |
| Linda (Collins) Blehm | Christine (Hiller) Barnett | Peggy (Barbour) Lefors |
| Gloria (Hite) Shrum | Cecil Moore | Ruth (Freeman) Rowan |
| Coach Shirley (Roop) Werner | ||
|
The cheerleaders listed below were selected for the Hall of Fame during the Hall of Fame Luncheon held at Fishersville United Methodist Church January 26, 2013 for their outstanding performance during the 1981-1982 season during which they were selected as the best cheerleading team during the 1982 Mason-Dixon Tournament. |
|
1981-1982 Cheerleaders |
||
| Brenda (Ridgeway) Bourne | Tammy Giovannetti | Elizabeth “Buffie” Forbes-Hatfield |
| Rhonda Jennings | Ted Jones | Michele (Paoni) VanBoxlaere |
| Cheryl (Gochenour) Rader-Zaso | Roberta “Bobbie” Dietz | |
|
The players listed below were selected for the Hall of Fame during the VSDB 175th Anniversary Celebration at Best Western Plus Waynesboro Inn Conference Center October 4, 2014 for their outstanding performance during the 1980 and 1981 track seasons. |
| 1980 | Stuart Owens | Tracy Waddell |
| Earl Davis | Ted Jones | Tommy Cook |
| Mike Ruffin | Coach Jim Kiser | Billy Moore |
| Barry Crisman | Ass’t Coach Bob Blakey | Earl Davis |
| Steve Daniels | Barry Crisman | |
| Dean Crouch | 1981 | Willie Cooley |
| Steve Hale | Tracy Parham | Shawn Rice |
| Donnie Dove | Mike Ruffin | Zachary Hodgins |
| Willie Cooley | Dean Crouch | James Bearden |
| Bobby Jones | Darrell Lipscomb | Ted Hodgins |
| Mark Stevens | Vernon Buggs | Mark Stevens |
| Keith Minnis | Willie Collier | Randy Wheeler |
| James Beardon | Ryland Braxton | Bobby Jones |
| Eric Patron | Marvin Millner | Steve Hale |
| Zachary Hodgins | Billy Lambert | Tommy Hoffman |
| Randy Wheeler | Tom Henderson | C.C. Copeland |
| Tommy Hoffman | Bucky Haney | Eric Patron |
| David Hare | Charles Ward | Coach Jim Kiser |
| Ted Hodgins | Ernest Ray | Ass’t Coach Bob Blakey |